Most of this information was compiled from the excellent book by the late Lee Calhoun, Jr. called "Old Southern Apples" (Revised and expanded edition). I highly recommend purchasing this book or at least checking it out from your library, because these dry tables leave out all the wonderful history and back-stories of these apples. He also has chapters on extinct apples, which give apple hunters some useful information they might use to rescue and revive some old valuable cultivars, apple cultivation practices and more detail on each apple's characteristics and synonyms. He also lists sources for trees, but such lists tend to become outdated quickly, which is why I don't include them here.

His book was published by Chelsea Green Publishing Company in 2010. ISBN 978-1-60358-294-0

Some additional information was gleaned from Tom Burford's excellent book:  Burford, Tom. 2013. Apples of North America. ISBN 978-1-60469-249-5.
Table 1.

Fruit Characteristics

Cultivar Aliases RipeWhere RipeQualitative RipeStart RipeEnd Keeper KeepsTill WaxyinStorage Fruit Size FruitSkinColor Crispness Aroma texture flavor Sweetness Acidity Juicy? OriginState County/Province FruitComments
Abram


10 11 excellent April yes 3 dull brownish red

dense, fine-grained

3
unknown
not fit to eat until January
Accordian


8 8


5 Pinkish-red over yellow 5
Fine-grained

3 4 NC Rockingham
Alexander


8 9


7
4



3
Russia

Alexander’s Ice Cream
NC
6.75 9


4 Red-striped 4


2 3 4 NC Mecklenburg
Allum Rockingham Red

9 10
April
4 Purple-red 4
Fine-grained

3 4 NC Rockingham
American Beauty


9 9


6 red over yellow
yes tender

2 4 MA

American Golden Russet Bullock Pippin

9 10


3 russet over yellow 5 yes tender, fine-grained

3 4 NJ

American Summer Pearmain

early 7 8 no

4 striped 5 yes very tender

2 4 NJ

Amy

early 7.5 7.9


3.5 bright red






NC Stokes
Andy Reed


8 8


6 red






NC Cherokee
Arkansas Black


10 10 yes
yes 4 black 5 no Fine-grained; very firm

3.5 3 AR

Arkansas Sweet


9.75 10 fair

4 dark red 4


2

AR

Arthur
















NC Ashe
Asterus


7.75 8


4 bright red









Atha


6.75 7.25


8 pale yellow








very closely resembles Yellow Transparent
Aunt Cora’s


10 10 yes

3.5 red 2
Fine-grained
2 3 3 NC Bath
Aunt Rachel


7 7


4 red striped over yellow




3 4 NC Chatham
Aunt Sally


9.75 10


5 red splotched with golden russet

tender

3
VA

Autumn Strawberry
NC
8 8


4.5 red 5
Fine-grained; tender

3 4 NY

Bald Mountain


10 11 yes

4.5 bright red

Fine-grained

2 4 NC

Baldwin
Piedmont (below 1500 ft.)
8 9 when grown in cold climates

5.5 red striped over yellow 5
firm, rather tender good
3 4 MA

Ball’s Choice


9 10 yes

4 red 5
Fine-grained

3 4 TN Giles
Balsam


9 10


4 red 5



2 3 NC Ashe
Baltimore Monstrous Pippin


















identical with Gloria Mundi
Bart


8 8


3 medium red






GA Rabun
Beach

late

excellent

5 striped

moderately coarse fair
3 2


Beauty of the World


11 11 good

5 striped red

Fine-grained, firm

3
NC

Beckham’s Seedling


8 9


6 dark purple-red 5
slightly tough

3
NC Warren beautiful apple
Beecher


7.75 8


5.7 dark red 5



3 3 NC

Belcher Mountain


10 10


4 striped






VA

Belmont

late




5 light yellow with russet marbling

very tender

3.5 3

not adapted to most of the South
Ben Davis


10 10 good

4.5 red over yellow 1
firm, moderately coarse

2 4


Benham


7 8 poor


4.3 Greenish-yellow

Fine-grained sugar and acid perfectly balanced, nutty overtones 2.7 3 4


Benoni


7 7


3.8 red over yellow 5
Fine-grained

3 4 MA

Bentley's Sweet


10 10 excellent May
4 red 5
Fine-grained, firm, tender sweet 3
3


Betsy Deaton


9 10


4 red 5




3 NC

Bevan’s Favorite Striped June, Bivins, Early Bevans


7.75 7.75 poor

4.3 striped 5
Fine-grained

3 4 NJ
becomes dry & mealy quickly
Big Red


10 11


6 red over yellow

tender

3.5 4


Big Stem


7.75 7.75


4.3 yellow w/ tan russet









Billy Brown


7 8


3 yellow









Bishop


8 8


3.8 light yellow 5
Fine-grained

3 4 England

Bismarck


8 8


7 red over yellow 5



3.3 4 New Zealand

Black Amish
Pittsboro
9 9 yes two months in refrigeration
5 red over yellow 5
Fine-grained, firm

3.5 3 PA

Black Apple Jersey Black, Cherryville Black

7.75 7.75


3 Purple-red 5



3 5


Black Gilliflower


9 10 poor

5 Dark, dull red
yes firm, coarse
2.7
3

identical to a Southern apple called Crow’s Egg, but not the northern one; becomes mealy quickly
Black Jack



















Blacktwig Paragon

10 October


6 red

firm

2 4

tart when picked and mellows
Blairmont


7.75 8 no

4.5 dark red

Fine-grained, melting

3 4 GA
turns mealy if overripe
Bloomless Coreless
late




2.3 Greenish-yellow




3.5 4


Blue Ridge King


8 9


5.7 striped


delicious





Boger


9 10


4 greenish, russeted



2.7
3 NC

Bower's Nonpareil Big Green

8 8


6 pale red

tender

2 4 VA

Branch


8 8


4 green






NC Brunswick
Brichel Sweet

late

good

2 Greenish-yellow






NC

Brogan







6 red

firm rich flavor akin to Blacktwig and original Delicious

4 TN

Brogden


7.75 8.25


4.5 green 2


3
2 AL

Brooks


7 8


6 red over greenish-yellow




2 4


Bryson’s Seedling

late 10.75 10.75 excellent March
6 green





4 NC Jackson
Buckeye Beauty


10 10 yes

4.3 bright yellow 5



2 4


Buckingham

Mid-season 9 9 yes November
6 striped

tender high
3.5 4


Bud Wolf


9 10













probably identical to Wolf River
Buff


9 10


8


tender, somewhat coarse

3 3 NC Haywood mealy when fully ripe
Buncombe


7 8


6 red striped 4
Fine-grained tasty
3 4

not pretty
Burl


8 8



yellow
yes
spicy
5
KY

Burning Green


8 9.25 good

3.5 pale yellow









Calvin


7.75 8


5.7 yellow 2



2 3 VA

Camack’s Sweet


9.75 10


4.5 yellow with a blush
yes firm
2
4


Cannon Pearmain


10 11 yes (excellent according to Burford)

4 green 5 yes firm

4 4


not good at lower elevations
Captain Davis


7.75 8


4.5 red over green 4 extreme Fine-grained

3 3 MS

Carolina Baldwin


















identical to Royal Limbertwig
Carolina Pippin



November













identical to Fall Pippin
Carolina Red June


6 7


3 bright red

Fine-grained, tender

4 3


Carter’s Blue


9.75 9.75 poor


5.5
5 yes
high
2 4 AL

Catawba


8 8


6 light yellow
yes Fine-grained, tender
2 3



Cathead







8 Greenish-yellow


not flavorful





Cauley


8 9 good for its season


7 green 5



2
MS

Chandler



October














Chatham Sweet


8 9


4 Greenish-yellow






NC

Chenango Strawberry


7 9


4.5 striped
slight tender

3 4

best to pick when skin begins to develop a milky appearance
Chesapeake


9 9


5 red





4 KY
Rome Beauty seedling
Chimney


8 8


4 light green 4
Fine-grained

3 4 VA

Clapper Flat


9 9


5 striped

tender

2 4 NY Albany
Clarke's Pearmain Golden Pearmain

9 October


4 orangish 5
Fine-grained, firm

3 4


Clark’s Orange


8 9


5 orange




3 4 OH
ripe fruit is sticky
Coble’s Wilder


7 7


4 yellow 2

high
3 4 NC Guilford
Coe


8.75 8.75


6 striped 5
tender

3 4 NC Guilford
Coffelt Beauty


10 10 very good

4.5 red over yellow

firm, rather fine-grained, somewhat tender

3 3

better than Ben Davis; improves in storage
Coffey Seedling


10 October


5



rich
2 4

possibly identical to Dula’s Beauty
Collins Champion
late
January excellent

5 bright dark red

very firm, rather coarse no better than Ben Davis
3.5 3 AR Washington
Collins June


6 7


6 Greenish-yellow 1
soft

3



Conrad














3



Cothren


8 9


6 yellow




3 4 NC Wilkes
Cotton


8 8


6 very pale yellow, almost white

very tender






Crack


10 10


3 striped 4


2.7
4


Critt

very late




1




1 5


not good till after Christmas
Crow’s Egg


8.75 9


4 Red-blushed








hangs well on the tree
Cullasaga


10 October


5 brick red
yes dense, tender
2.7 2 4


Davidson Sweeting


7.75 8


4.5 yellow with faint stripes 1
rather soft, fine-grained
3
4 NC Davidson
Deaderick


9.75 10


6 lemon yellow

breaking, fine-grained

2 4 TN Washington
Delicious


9 10 no
no 5 red

breaking, moderately fine-grained distinctive, I would say has a hint of astringency 3 2 4 IA Madison
Devine


7 8


5 red w/ stripes

Fine-grained

3



Disharoon


9 10


4 Green, occasional yellow on sunny side 4


3
3 GA Habersham
Doctor Newby

9 10 yes
yes 6 red striped over yellow

moderately fine-grained

3 4 PA

Doctor Matthews


9 9


4.5 yellow w/ some red 5 yes Fine-grained “organized cider” 2.7
5 TN

Domine


10 10 yes

4 red and russet-streaked
somewhat very firm, breaking, almost coarse

3 4 VA

Donce


8 8


6 light green with red overtones 5
firm

3 4 NC Wilkes
Duchess of Oldenburg


7 7


5 striped over yellow 3
tender

3 4 Russia
often drops unripe fruit & becomes mealy quickly
Dula Beauty


9 9 fair

7 dark red with stripes 5
tender

2 4 NC Caldwell
Dumpling



October














Durham


8 9


3 russet over yellow 5
firm

5



Early Harvest


6 7


4.5 clear pale yellow 5
tender

4 4


Early Joe


7.5 7.5


3 red over pale greenish yellow

tender rich
2 4 NY Ontario
Early Red Bird


6 6 no

3 red 1
soft, mealy, mushy

4 2 Canada New Brunswick
Early Red Margaret


6 7


3 striped 5
Fine-grained

4 4 England
quickly becomes mealy
Early Ripe


6.75 6.75


4.5 dull pale yellow 5
moderately coarse, tender

3.5 4 PA Adams
Early Strawberry


6.75 7


3 striped
yes


4 3 NY
quickly becomes mealy
Edward’s Winter


9.75 10 good April/May
4 Greenish-yellow

Fine-grained, tender

3 4 NC Chatham
Emerging Blaze


9 9











WV

Enos


7 7


4.5 light yellow 5


2.7
4


Esopus Spitzenburg


9.75 9.75 yes December
4.5 red 5 yes tender

3.5 4 NY Ulster best after stored in refrigerator a couple of months
Fairgrove


9 9 very good

4 pale red 4
Fine-grained
2
4 NC Catawba
Fall Orange Hogpen, Summer Orange

8.75 9


6 pale yellow 5 yes moderately fine-grained

3 4 MA

Fall Pippin


8.75 9


6.2 clear yellow
yes almost fine-grained

3 4

not good at lower elevations
Fall Premium


9 10


4.5 yellow with a blush 5
firm

3 4 NC

Fallawater


9 9 good February
6 drab red over green

tender, somewhat coarse

2 4

better above 1500 ft. in South
Fameuse


9 9 good

4 Greenish-yellow
yes very tender

3 4


Fanny


9 9


4 crimson

tender

2 4 PA Lancaster
Farthing’s No Bloom


9 9


4 bright yellow

Fine-grained
3
1 NC Watauga
Fired Sweet


7 7


3.5 greenish with a pink blush






NC

Flat Fall Cheese


9 9


4 light yellow w/ rosy blush 4


2.7
4


Flat Fallawater


9 9 good

5.5 light green 3
tender

2 4 NC

Fleming


8 9


5 light yellow



2.7
4


Floyd Richmond


7 8


4 striped




3



Foot Around

early summer




4 light green






NC Montgomery
Foust


10 10


5 yellow
yes tender

3 2 NC Guilford
Fugate


7 7


5 Yellowish-green 5
Fine-grained

3 4 TN Cooke
Fyan


9 10


4 red with blue bloom 5



2 4 MO
Ben Davis X Jonathan
Gable


9 10


4 light red






NC Randolph
Gano


9 10


5 dark, solid crimson

firm

2 3


George Mack


9 10


3 yellow

soft, fine-grained
3

TN

Gilmore’s Sweetening


7 7


4 Striped over pale yellow



3 1
NC Guilford
Gilpin


9 9 excellent June
4 red 4
firm, coarse, becoming tender & crisp in storage
2.7
3 VA
not fit to eat until it’s stored for several months
Glass


















identical to Fall Orange
Globe


9 9














Gloria Mundi


9 9


8 Greenish-yellow 4
coarse

4



Golden Harvey Brandy

8 9


3 yellow, russeted 5


2
4 England
beats all other apples of its season in taste
Golden Pippin


9 10


5 golden yellow
yes coarse, tender

3 4 New England

Golden Reinette


9 9


2.5 golden yellow 5



3 4 England

Golden Sweet


6 7


5 pale yellow
yes Fine-grained, firm, tender
4 1 4 CT

Gragg Winter Queen

9 10 good

4 red




3 4 NC Caldwell
Grandaddy


8 9


4 red









Grandmother Cheese


9 9


4.5 green with red on the sunny side

soft

2.7 4


Granny Christian


9 9


4 red









Granny Mack


9 10


3.5 golden russet 5


3
4 VA Carroll
Granny Neighbors


8 8


4 pale yellow




3
AL Clay
Gravenstein


7 7 poor

6 striped 5 yes tender

3.5 4


Green Cheese Green Skin, Green Crank, Yellow Crank, Southern Golden Pippin, Winter Cheese, Winter Greening, Southern Greening, Carolina Greening, Greening, Turner's Cheese, Crank, Southern Pippin, Green

9 10 good

4.5 deep green 5
tender

3 4


Green Pippin


9 9 good

4.5 green
yes


3 4 IN

Green River


8.5 8.75


4.5 red over green

tender

2 4


Grimes Golden


9 10 fair

4.5 yellow w/ some russet 5 yes firm, tender faint anise or licorice
3.5 4 WV Brooks
Grindstone

winter

excellent next winter
4 striped

firm

5 4


Grissom


8 8


4 green 1



3 4


Guyandotte


9 9


4.5 dull red 4
chewy

3 4 WV

Haas


9 9


5 red

tender

4 5


Hackworth


8 9


4.5 yellow
yes granular



GA Franklin
Hall


10 11 good

2 red
yes Fine-grained, tender best; saccharine, rich, luscious, vinous 3 3 4 NC Franklin
Hammond


9 9


4 orange over green






SC Spartanburg
Harris


8.5 8.5


4.5 yellow 5



4 4 NC Rockingham
Harrison
Virginia
10.25 10.25 good

3 yellow with distinctive black specks

tough rich 3
1 NJ Essex
Hayes Green


8 9


4.5 pale green









Haywood June
mountains
7.25 7.25


4 very dark red with prominent white spots









Hege


















no information
Henry Clay


6 7


4 Greenish-yellow

soft

4



Hewe’s Crab


9 10














Hickman


10 10 good

4 red over green 5
tender

2 4 KY Fulton Shockley seedling
Hightop Sweet


8.25 8.25


3.5 Greenish-yellow

tender
4
2 MA

Hillside


10 10 good

6 green with red on the sunny side

very firm

4 4


Hog Island Sweet


9 10


4.5 yellow striped w/ red 5 slight rather coarse, tender
4

NY Nassau
Hog Sweet


7.75 7.75


4 Yellowish-green



4

GA

Holland Pippin


7 9


7 pale green 4
slightly coarse

4 5


Hollow Log


6.75 8.25


6 deep yellow 5 yes tender most delicious, spicy

5 NC Rutherford
Holly


8 9


4.5 bright red

chewy
2.7 2 3 OH
Jonathan X Delicious
Honey Sweet Honey Cider

8 9


4 yellow









Hoover


9 10 good

6 dark red, almost black

firm, tender

3.5 3 SC Colleton
Horse


7.75 8


5 Greenish-yellow

firm

4 3


Hubbardston Nonsuch


9 9


5 dull brownish red
yes tender, rather fine-grained
2.5 3 4 MA Worchester not really suited to warm climates
Huffman Red


8 9


4.5 red 5



3 4 NC Alamance
Hunge


8 9


7 red overlaid with russet 5 yes
vinous 2.7
4 NC Wayne
Huntsman’s Favorite


9 9 good

6 deep yellow or greenish
yes firm

3 4 MO Howard one source disputes its keeping ability
Ingram


10 10 good February
4.5 dark red 5 yes firm

2 4 MO
one of Lee’s favorites
Isam


8 9


3 yellow striped w/ red 4



3 4 NC Stanley
Jake’s Seedling


7.75 8


4 dark red over yellow 5
Fine-grained

3 4 KY Russell won “best apple” in county fair for many years
Jarrett


9.75 9.75


4 striped






NC Watauga
Jefferis


8 8


3.5 clear waxen yellow 5



3 4 PA Chester
Jersey Black



November
February
4










Jim Day Day

6.75 8


5 striped 5


2.7 2 4 MS Simpson bronze medal winner at 1904 St. Louis expo
Jimbo







5 yellow








may be identical to Gloria Mundi
Joe Little


7 8


3 bright red

soft, fine-grained

4 4


John


8 9


4 yellow

firm

2 4


John Conner


8 9


3.7 bright red

Fine-grained

4
NC Wilkes
Johnny No Core


9 9


4.5 red




2
NC Ashe
Johnson Keeper


10 11.25 excellent Spring
4.5 dark red 5


3 3 4 Calhoun suggests NC MS

Jonalicious


9 9


4 dark red 5 yes Fine-grained

3 4 TX
probably no Jonathan in its heritage
Jonathan


9 10


4 dark red 5
tender sprightly, vinous
3 4 NY Ulster not adapted to most of the South
Juicy Fruit


10 10


4 greenish to pale yellow 5


3
3 TN

July Delicious


60 days before Delicious 7 8


3.5 pale yellow with red on the sunny side

Fine-grained, very tender
2.7
4 AL Cullman Hackworth X Delicious
July-August Go-No-Further


8.75 9


5 Purple-red









Junaluska


10 10


4 tan russet with a few orange-green blotches showing through

dense, fine-grained

3 2 NC Macon
June Sweeting


7 7


3.5 red

soft, fine-grained
3




Kane


8 9


3 red over yellow 5



3 4 DE Kent
Keener Seedling Rusty Coat

10.75 10.75 good Spring
3.5 brown russet 5
Fine-grained

3 4 NC Lincoln
Kennedy


7.5 7.5


4.5 bright red 5
chewy


4

two apples of different ripening seasons go by this name
Kimrome


9 9


7 red






GA Gilmer probably Rome Beauty X op
King David


8 9 good

4 deep red over green 5
firm

3 4 AR Washington seedling of Jonathan
King Luscious


9 10 good

5 red, striped 5
Fine-grained

2 4 NC Henderson
King Solomon


8 9


4.5 Orange-yellow

slightly coarse

2 3 GA

King Tom


8 8 fair October
4 dark red

tough



NC

Kinnaird’s Choice
central NC
9 10 excellent

4 dark red w/ scattered russet 5 yes moderately fine-grained; tender

2 4 TN

Lacy


8.75 9


4 striped

Fine-grained
2.7
4


Lady


8.75 9 good January
1.5 yellow w/ bright red on sunny side 5 yes firm, fine-grained
2.7 2 4 France

Lady Skin


9.75 9.75


4 yellow w/ pink blush 5



4 4


Lady Sweet


8 9 good

5 red 5 yes rather firm, tender

7 4


Ladyfinger


















synonym of Black Gilliflower
Langdon Morgan

7 9


4.5 dull light green

Fine-grained

2 3 TN Greene
Lawson’s Seedling


9.75 10


4.5 dull dark red 4
Fine-grained
3
4 NC Stokes
Lawver


9 10 excellent

5 red 5 somewhat firm, fine-grained

3 4


Leather Coat


9 10


4 Brownish-red russet 5



4
NC Wilkes
Lewis Green


8 9


5.5 Greenish-yellow

tender

3 4 NC Watauga
Appalachian Limbertwig


9.5 10 good

4 red
yes firm spicy

4


Sweet Limbertwig Victoria Limbertwig

9 10 excellent Spring
5 purple with large white dots

Fine-grained, tender
3
4 TN

Brushy Mountain Limbertwig


10 10 excellent June

dull red over yellow
yes
unusual aromatic flavor

5


Cane Creen Limbertwig


















“large and excellent strain of Red Limbertwig”
Ben Lomand Limbertwig







6 unusual red & green
yes firm


4


Myer’s Royal Limbertwig







8 red over yellow
very firm


4


Old Fashioned Limbertwig


11 11 good


Greenish-yellow with red blush; rough-skinned









Swiss Limbertwig








maroon with white pips








“The most unusual colored apple that I have ever seen.”
American Limbertwig


















possibly identical to Red Limbertwig
Black Limbertwig


9 10


4 bright red 5



3 4


Red Limbertwig


10 10 excellent

4 Greenish-yellow with red blush; rough-skinned

Fine-grained not high-flavored, but improves in storage
4 4


Royal Limbertwig


10.25 10.25 good

5 light red over greenish-yellow

tender, fine-grained

2 4


Levering Limbertwig
















VA Patrick tetraploid
Rose Limbertwig




good













Summer Limbertwig


8 9


4 pale yellow overlaid with stripes
yes tender, fine-grained

3 4 NC Guilford
Red Royal Limbertwig


9 10


4.5 dull red 5
rather coarse, tender
2.7
3

1 of Lee’s favorite eating apples
Rocky River Limbertwig



















Little Benny


8 8


2 dark red on green 4



4 3 NC Pamlico
Liveland Raspberry


7 7


5 striped 1
very tender, “like eating foam”, fine-grained

3.5 4 Lithuania
bruises easily
Longfield


8 9


4 waxen yellow 1
very tender

4 4 Russia

Long Stem


7 7


4.5 Greenish-yellow

tender rich buttery flavor like a pear

4


Lonnie’s Summer Giant


7 8


6 red striped over green 1
rather soft So-so
2 3

probably identical to Summer Champion
Lowell


8 10


6 rich yellow 5
rather firm, tender

3.5 5


Lowry


9 10 good

4 dark mahogany 5


2 2 4 VA

Lugar Red


9 9


4.5 dark red 5
Fine-grained

3 4


Magnum Bonum


9 9 no

3.5 light red
yes Fine-grained, tender

2 4


Maiden’s Blush


7 8


4 pale green

tender, fine-grained

4 3 NJ Burlington
Mann

late

good

5 deep yellow




2 4 NY Oswego
Mary McKinney








striped






VA

Mary Reid


8 8


4.5 red 5



4 4 NC Caswell
Mattamuskeet


9 10 excellent June
3.5 rusty red

firm

4 3 NC Hyde by late Spring develops a “delightful” flavor
May


5.75 6 no

2 light yellow

tender, quickly becoming mealy

4 4


McIntosh


9 9 no

4.5 green with pale blush in the South 5 yes firm

3.5 5 Ontario Dundas not for the South
McLean


8 9


4.5 light red 5



4 4 NC Iredell different than the Canadian apple of the same name
Means Seedling


9 10 excellent

4 red 5



3 4 KY

Melungeon Gold


















no useful information
Milam


9 10 good

3 light red; a russeted variant may exist 5
tender, slightly coarse

3 4


Miles Stadler


9 9


4 red

firm
3

NC Stokes
Mississippi Pippin


9 9


4.5 pale green









Missouri Pippin


10 11 good

4.5 red

slightly coarse, breaking

3
MO Johnson
Mitchell


10 11 fair

5.5 Orangish-red 4
Fine-grained
2.7 2 4 WV Logan doesn’t ripen properly in common refrigeration
Mitchell Sweet


8.75 9


3.5 pale yellow

chewy
3
2 NC Alexander
Mongolian


9 9


5.5 bright red




3
NC Wilkes
Morgan’s Christmas


9 9


5.5 dark red 4
Fine-grained
3
4 NC Rutherford
Mosey








green with pale stripes




3
KY

Mother


8 9


4 red
distinctive tender, fine-grained

2 4 MA Worchester become bland when overripe
Mother Bud


8 9











NC Avery
Mountain Beauty


12 1


3.5 red

tender
2.7 2 4 VA Albemarle
Mountain Boomer


8 9


7 pale yellow

firm exceptional for a large apple

4


Mountain Rose


9 9


3.5 lemon yellow 5
tender


4 NC Wilkes
Mrs. Bryan


8 9


6 pale red over green

tender, coarse


2 GA Rabun
Munson Sweet


8 8


5 pale yellow

tender, fine-grained
4
3 MA
skin separates easily from flesh
Muskmelon Sweet


9 10


5.5 pale greenish-yellow 2
Fine-grained
3
2 VA

Newtown Pippin


10 10 good February
5 Yellowish-green 5 yes tender, fine-grained sprightly
3 4 NY

Nickajack


10 10 good

5 dull red

firm

4 4 NC

North Carolina Keeper


9 10 very good Spring
3.5 red 5



3 4


Northern Spy


10 10 excellent

6 striped 5 yes tender, rather fine-grained spicy
3 4 NY Ontario not adapted to most of the South
Northwestern Greening


10 10 good

5 pale yellow 4
medium

2 4 WI Waupaca
Old English Milam


8 8


4.3 dull red









Oliver


9 10 excellent

4.5 red 5
rather fine-grained

2 4 AR Washington
Ooten


8.5 8.75


8 green






WV Mingo
Opalescent


8 9

yes 5.5 dark red 5 yes


2 4 MI Barry
Ophir


8.75 9


4 red 5



2 5 NC

Ortley


10 10

yes 5 yellow

tender, fine-grained

3 4 NJ

Ozark Beauty


8 9


4.5 lemon yellow 5


3
4 MO
probably identical to Ozark Gold
Parks’ Pippin Gilmer Pippin

9.5 9.5 good

6 Greenish-yellow




5
GA Gilmer
Parmer


7 8


3 deep yellow

Fine-grained

4
VA
deepest yellow flesh of any apple
Paw


9.25 9.25


4 yellow 5



3 4 NC Alexander
Pennock

late

good

6 red

tender, coarse
2.7 3 4 PA Delaware
Perkins


9 10


6 dark red 5



3 4 NC

Perry Russet


9.75 10


4 pale greenish-yellow 5



2 4


Pewaukee


10 11 good

5 red

moderately firm

3 4 WI Waukesha
Phifer


8 9


4 whitish yellow




5
NC Iredell
Pilot


10 10 excellent

6 dull red
slight rather firm, tender

2 4 VA Nelson best at higher elevations
Pineapple


9.75 9.75


4 whitish yellow 5
firm

5



Pinky


8.5 10


4 Purplish-red






VA

Polly Eades


7 8


4.5 light greenish-yellow with faint blush or stripes on sunny side
yes tender

4 4 KY Henderson browns quickly; rots easily
Polly Sweet


7.75 8


4 pale greenish-yellow



2
4 NC Haywood
Pomme Grise


8.75 9


3.5 russet over greenish-gray skin 5
firm, fine-grained

3 4


Porter


8 9


5 clear greenish-yellow 5 yes tender, fine-grained

3 4 MA Sherburne fruit size highly variable
Potomac


9.75 9.75 excellent

5 Purplish-red

firm

5
KY Fleming
Potts


9 9


6 yellow, blushed




4 1 NC

Pound


8.75 9


5.5 pale yellow









Pound Pippin Fall Pippin

















identical with Fall Pippin
Primate


7 7


4.5 Greenish-yellow 5 yes tender

3.5
NY Onondaga bruises easily
Prissy Gum


8 8









5



Pryor’s Red


10 10 good

5 russet over dull red

tender, fine-grained

3 2 VA Botetourt highly variable fruit quality by soil type
Pumpkin Sweet Pound Sweet

8 8 poor

7 pale gren with yellow near the stem

firm
4
2 CT Hartford
Queen


9 9


5.5 red 4



3 4 KY

Rabun Bald


9 10


5.5 yellow with red blush in the sun

breaking, fine-grained

2 4 GA Rabun
Rainbow


8 9


8 striped

Fine-grained


4 MO

Ralls Janet


10 10 excellent

4 red 5
Fine-grained

2 4


Rambo


9 10 fair

4.5 red 6 yes firm, tender, fine-grained

3 4 DE

Rattle Core


7 7


4 striped

tender

2 4


Rawley


9 9


4 red over yellow






VA Scott
Reaser Green


11 11 excellent April
4.5 green






VA Lee
Rebel


9 9


4 red on yellow




3
VA Rappahannock
Red Astrachan


6 7 no

4 red 5 yes rather coarse, tender

4.5 3 Russia
bruises easily; ripeness should be based on the presence of waxy bloom
Red Bietigheimer


8 9


7 red

firm, coarse, somewhat tough

4 5 Germany

Red Canada


9 10 good

4 red 5 yes tender, rather fine-grained

3 5


Red Cathead


9 10


6 red

tender

3 4 VA

Red Cheese


7 8.25


4 red 5



3 4


Red Delight


9 10


5.5 dark red 5
firm sprightly 3 2 4 AL Talladega
Red Detroit


8.75 9 no

4 green with pale stripy blush in the sun 4
coarse
2 5 4

Calhoun says they are “subacid”, but I’m going with my own experience here.
Red Hackworth


8 9


3.5 red 4
Fine-grained
3
4 AL

Red Rebel


8 9


3.5 Purplish-red 5
Fine-grained

3 3

skin can be bitter & should be peeled
Red Reese


10.25 10.25


4.5 lovely red



2.7 2
AL Randolph
Red Winter Sweet

late




4 deep red on yellow

slightly coarse
4




Regent


9 10 good

4 red on yellow 5 banana
suggestive of Delicious, but more sprightly and with a hint of banana

5 MN
Red Duchess X Delicious
Republican Pippin


9 9


6 red

tender

3 4 PA Lycoming
Reverend Morgan


8 8


4.5 Pinkish-red over green 5
Fine-grained

2 4 TX Harris
Rexrode Beauty


10 10


5.7 light red






WV

Rhode Island Greening


9 10 good

6 Greenish-yellow 5 yes tender, fine-grained sprightly
4 4 RI Newport not good at lower elevations
Roanoke


9 9



red

firm

2
VA
Red Rome X Schoharie
Robertson Red


10 10 excellent

4 dark red






TN Robertson
Romanite


9 10


3 clear red

Fine-grained
2.7 2 4

often confused with Gilpin & Shockley
Roman Stem


9 9


4 pale greenish

tender
2.7
4 NJ

Rome Beauty
mountains
9 10 good

7 deep red 3
firm “sprightly” (I would say “bland”)
1 4 OH Lawrence
Roxbury Russet


9 10 fair

4 russet over dull green

breaking, somewhat coarse sprightly
3.5 4 MA Suffolk
Andrews Rusty Coat


7.75 7.75


2 tan russet 5
Fine-grained

2 3 NC Chatham many apples are called Rusty Coat
Sally Gray


7.75 8


3.5 light yellow with blush on the sunny side 5
brittle, fine-grained, dense
2.7
4


Salome


10 10 excellent in the OH valley

3.5 pale yellow 5
tender sprightly
3.5 4 IL LaSalle
Sam Apple


8 9


4 brick red 5
collapsing

2 3 GA Stephens
Sam Hunt


9 10


4.5 red






MS Hinds
Sam Whitson


9 9


5.5 striped






NC Mitchell
San Jacinto


7 7


4 Pinkish-red with broken stripes 4
Fine-grained

2 3 GA
identical to Red Cheese
Schell


8 9


4.5 clear yellow 4 very Fine-grained

2 4 WV Grant
Schumacher


7.75 8


5.7 bright red over yellow 4



3 3 Germany

Scott’s Winter


9 10 good

3.5 bright red 2
Fine-grained

3 4 VT Orleans
Shell


7 7


4.5 bright red over yellow 4

faint pear 2.7
4 AL Escambia
Shenandoah


9 9



solid red

firm

4
VA
Winesap X Opalescent
Sherrill


10 11


4 striped 5
rather coarse

2 3 NC

Shockley Horse Bud

10 10 excellent August
3.5 bright red 5


2.7 2 4 GA Jackson
Short Core


10 10 excellent June
4 Purplish-red

Fine-grained

3 4 KY Madison from Berea
Sine Qua Non


7 7


4 pale yellow
yes tender, fine-grained

3.5 4 NY

Slabside


8 8


4 bright red over green 4


3 2 4


Slope


10 10


5 red 5
firm, fine-grained

4



Smith Seedling


9 10 good

4 brick red 4
Fine-grained

3 3 NC Stokes
Smith’s Cider


10 10 fair

4.5 red on yellow 5
tender, breaking

2 4 VA Frederick
Smith’s Seedling of Mississippi


7 7


5.7 pale greenish-yellow

slightly coarse, tender

2 3 MS Wilkinson
Smokehouse


8 9


4.5 red 5 yes firm

3 4 PA Lancaster
Snuff


10 10 good

3 Purplish-red 5
firm

5



Sops of Wine


6.75 7


4 dark red
yes tender

2 2 England

Sour June


7 7


3.5 pale yellow 5
Fine-grained

5 4 NC

Sparger


9 10 excellent

3.5 striped

firm

3 3


Spotted Pippin


8 9


3.5 bright yellow 5



3 4


St. Clair


7.5 7.75


4.5 red 4
Fine-grained

3 4 IL St. Clair
Stafford


7.25 7.25


4.5 striped

tender, fine-grained

3 4


Stark


9 9 good

5 dull red 5
firm, coarse

2 3 OH Stark
Starr
Piedmont (below 1500 ft.)
6.75 7 good

7 pale greenish-yellow 5 yes moderately fine-grained, tender sprightly
3.5 5 NJ Gloucester
Stayman


10 10 good
no 5 striped on green

breaking, rather fine-grained, firm sprightly 1.5 3.5 4 KS Leavenworth prone to splitting, especially near ripeness after rain
Striped Early Harvest


7.75 7.75


7 striped

tender superior to Early Harvest according to originator
3 4 NC Wilkes
Striped June


6 6


2 striped

soft, fine-grained

5 2


Stump


9 9


3.5 red
yes tender, fine-grained sprightly
3.5 4 NY Chili
Stump The World


10 10


6 yellow

rather coarse

2 3


Sugar


10 10


4 dark red

crumbly
4

NC Pamlico
Sugar Loaf Pippin


7 9


5 pale yellow

firm

3.5 3


Sulser Red


9 10


4.3 solid red 5



2 3 WV

Summer Banana


9 9


4.5 yellow
banana




NC Marion
Summer Champion


8 8


4.5 yellow




3 4 TX Parker
Summer Cheese


8 9


5 yellow

tender

5 4


Summer King


7.75 8


5 red

brittle, fine-grained, tender

2 4 NC

Summer Ladyfinger


7.5 7.5


6 Yellowish-green with some red on sunny side 5
Fine-grained

3 3


Summer Pippin


7 9


5 yellow

very tender

3 3 NY

Summer Pound Royal


7 8


6 Greenish-yellow

tender, fine-grained

2 4


Summer Queen


7 8


5 striped
yes slightly coarse spicy
3 4


Summer Rambo


8 9


4.5 striped

breaking, tender, somewhat coarse

2 5 France

Summer Rose


6.75 7


3 waxen bright red 5
tender, fine-grained sprightly
3.5 4 NJ

Sunday Sweet


7.75 8


2.5 light yellow
very firmer than Sweet Bough richer flavor than Sweet Bough 3




Surprise







2 yellow








pink flesh
Sutton Beauty


8 9


4.5 waxen with some crimson 5
Fine-grained sprightly
3.5 4 MA Worchester
Swaar


10 10 fair

5.5 yellow
yes firm, becoming rather tender in storage, fine-grained exquisite after storage, not good before
2 4 NY
too little acid to be good for cooking
Sweet Bough


7.75 7.75


5.5 pale greenish-yellow to almost white 5
very tender bitter when unripe, very sweet when ripe 4
4


Sweet Dixon


9 9


3.5 striped 4


2
4 NC

Sweet Lannie


7 8


3.5 yellow with some russet






VA

Sweet Russet


7 8


4 light green, heavily russeted 5


3
4


Sweet Winesap


9 9 good

4.5 red with narrow carmine stripes 4
tender, fine-grained
4
4 PA
Mid-August ripening in Coal Mtn., GA
Taliafero
western VA
9.75 9.75


1 white streaked with red




5 5 VA Gloucester the juiciest apple know to Thomas Jefferson
Tanner’s Winter


10 10


4 pale purplish-red over whitish yellow

coarse

2 3 NC Granville
Tanyard Seedling

winter 10 10


4 greenish with a faint blush

chewy

3 4 GA

Tarbutton


8 8


3 striped






GA Cherokee
Taylor Sweet


8 8


4 stripes over pale yellow 4
Fine-grained

2 3 NC Yancey
Ten Ounce


9 10


4 striped

somewhat chewy, almost fine-grained

2 4 NC

Tenderskin


10 10


4 red over yellow
yes very tender, fine-grained sprightly
3.5 4 SC
likely several apples use this name
Terry Winter


10 November excellent

3 “dull strawberry red with a few borken stripes and a heavy gray bloom” 5
Fine-grained “unique ‘nutty’ flavor”
2 4 GA Fulton
Tetofsky


6 7


4 red with whitish bloom

tender, slightly coarse

5 4 Russia

Tewksbury Winter Blush

winter

well

3










Thompson of Mississippi


7.75 8


4 golden russet and red blush on the sunny side over green background 2
Fine-grained

4 2 MS Hinds
Tolman Sweet


9 9 no

4 whitish yellow 1
firm, fine-grained, not tender
3
3


Tom Jones Seedling


8.75 8.75


5 green with slight bronze or reddish blush 5
firm

4
NC Buncombe
Tommy


8 9 good

4.5 light green

tender, fine-grained

3 4 NC Randolph
Tompkins King


9 9


6 red w/ stripes 5 yes tender, rather coarse

3 4 NJ Warren not adapted to the South
Tony


9 10


2.5 light greenish-yellow 4
Fine-grained

3 3 NC

Tucker


7 9.25


4 yellow with a rosy blush and some striping 4
Fine-grained

3 3 NC Guilford
Turley Winesap


9 10


4.5 red 5



3 4 IN Orange
Twenty Ounce


8 9 poor

8 red w/ stripes

moderately tender, coarse not flavorful
3 4 NY

Van Hoy possibly York
late
December very good June
5 dull red w/ stripes 5
slightly coarse

2 4 NC Forsyth
Vandevere


9 October very good March
4 Greenish-yellow w/ faint red stripes

firm, tender
2.7 2 4 DE New Castle many apples with this name
Vandever June


7 8


4 red over pale greenish yellow






NC

Vine


10 October rather well

4 yellow 5
Fine-grained

3 4 VA Patrick
Virginia Beauty


9 10


5 Purplish-red

tender, fine-grained like eating astringent cotton 2.7 2 1 VA Carroll Lee & I have very different opinions on the quality of this apple
Virginia Greening


9 October
March
5 Greenish-yellow w/ light blush

dense, coarse, breaking
2.7 3
VA

Walker's Yellow



October
February












Walter Tibbs


9 10


4 red over green






VA Bath
Watermelon


9 9


3.5 red blotches over greenish-yellow









Wealthy


8 8


4.5 striped 5
tender, moderately fine-grained

3 5 MN Hennepin not adapted to most of the South
Western Beauty


8 8


5 striped

moderately tender

2 3 PA Lancaster
White Winter Pearmain


9 10 fair

4.5 pale yellow 5 yes tender, fine-grained
2.7 3 4


Williams Favorite


7 7


4.5 red

tender, breaking

2 3 MA Suffolk
White Milan

late

good

3










Willow Twig


10 October very good March
4.5 red 5
not very tender, coarse not high-flavored
3 4


Wilson




very good 6 months












Wilson June


7 8


5 Purplish-red 5



3 4 AR Washington
Wine


10 10


5.5 red 5
firm

3 4 DE

Winesap


9 10 good March
4 red 5
firm, fine-grained sprightly, winy, tangy 2.5 3.5 5 NJ

Winter Banana


9 9


5.5 bright pale yellow 5 yes tender, fine-grained absent
3 4 IN Cass Lee & I have very different opinions on the quality of this apple; my opinion of this apple was formed from fruit purchased at orchards in Ellijay. I never grew it.
Winter Cheese


10 10 good

4 yellow striped w/ red 5
tender

3 5 VA Brunswick
Winter Jon Sour Jon, Winter John Pittsboro very late, latest in Calhoun collection; late November/ December 10.75 December


1.5 pale, dull yellow

a little tough distinctive
4.5 4
southern Applalachians
Winter May


10 10


4 Greenish-yellow, occasional faint pink blush; dots small, whitish w/ russet centers

Fine-grained

2 4 NC Iredell
Winter Sweet Paradise


9 9 good

5.5 Yellowish-green
yes tender, fine-grained Pear-like 3
4 PA Lancaster
Wolf River


9 9


7 red 1
soft, coarse, tender absent
3 3 WI Waupaca my opinion based on apples purchased in the N. GA mountains
World’s Best


8 8


3 striped 4
granular

2 3 NC Graham
Wrixparent


6 6


6 green 5
Fine-grained sprightly
3.5
DE Kent tetraploid
Yankee Sweet


8 9


4 Yellowish-green 4
Fine-grained
2
4 VA Floyd
Yates


10 11 very good Spring
2 red
yes tender
2.7 2 4 GA Fayette
Yellow Bellflower Yellow Sheepnose

9 9


highly variable yellow 5 yes firm, rather tender

4 4 NJ Burlington
Yellow Hardin


8 9


3.5 bright, waxy yellow









Yellow June


6.75 7


4 Greenish-yellow

tender

4 4


Yellow Potts


8.75 8.75
a couple of weeks
4 dull yellow




5



Yellow Transparent


6 7


5 transparent pale yellow

tender, fine-grained sprightly
4.5 4 Russia
quickly becomes dry
York Imperial


9 10 good

5 Brownish-red russet 5
firm, slightly coarse sprightly
3.5 4 PA York
Key:
Ripening Month:  Given as the numerical month most of the time and for no good reason sometimes given as the name of the month. Unconstrained by math, in this table whole numbers indicate nothing more specific than the month, whereas fractions indicate the period within the month. Thus 10.25 is early October, whereas "10" indicates sometime within that month. By my insane way of making this table, therefore, 10.25 may come before 10. Make sense?
Fruit Size:   1= crabapple size, 2= small, 4 = medium, 6 = large & 8 = very large
Crispness:  1 = not crisp; 4 = moderately crisp; 5 = crisp; 6 = very crisp (like 'Honeycrisp' or 'Pixie Crunch')
Sweetness:  1 =1 not sweet; 2 = slightly sweet; 3 = sweet; 4 = very sweet.
Acidity:  1 = little acid or "mild"; 2 = "mild subacid"; 3= subacid; 4 = tartish; 5 = acid or sour
Juciness:  1= dry; 2 = not very juicy; 3 = moderately juicy; 4 = juicy; 5 = very juicy



Table 2.

Uses

Cultivar Cider 2X alcohol Brix Jelly Drying Fresh Butter Applesauce Cooking Baking Freezing Canning Pie Brandy Vinegar Preserves Frying OtherUses UsageComments
Abram used for
















Accordian



used for












Alexander

















Alexander’s Ice Cream

















Allum

















American Beauty

















American Golden Russet used for 14
excellent excellent












American Summer Pearmain



best
excellent










Amy

















Andy Reed

















Arkansas Black

















Arkansas Sweet

















Arthur

















Asterus

















Atha

















Aunt Cora’s

















Aunt Rachel

















Aunt Sally

















Autumn Strawberry

















Bald Mountain

















Baldwin

















Ball’s Choice

















Balsam

















Baltimore Monstrous Pippin

















Bart


used for


used for









Beach

















Beauty of the World

















Beckham’s Seedling

















Beecher

















Belcher Mountain

















Belmont

















Ben Davis


very good average

used for good








Benham


excellent very good
excellent

excellent excellent



good


Benoni

















Bentley's Sweet used for



used for













Betsy Deaton

















Bevan’s Favorite



used for



used for









Big Red


used for


used for









Big Stem

















Billy Brown

















Bishop

















Bismarck

















Black Amish

















Black Apple Cherryville Black
















Black Gilliflower

















Black Jack

















Blacktwig

















Blairmont

















Bloomless Coreless
















Blue Ridge King



used for












Boger


used for






used for





Bower's Nonpareil

















Branch

















Brichel Sweet

















Brogan



best












Brogden



used for

used for









Brooks

















Bryson’s Seedling

















Buckeye Beauty

















Buckingham used for

used for used for

used for









Bud Wolf

















Buff


used for
used for
used for









Buncombe

















Burl

















Burning Green

















Calvin



excellent






used for




Camack’s Sweet

















Cannon Pearmain used for

used for used for

used for







general purpose

Captain Davis

















Carolina Baldwin

















Carolina Pippin

















Carolina Red June good









exceptional





Carter’s Blue



used for













Catawba

















Cathead


good

good good









Cauley


used for
used for



used for









Chandler

















Chatham Sweet

















Chenango Strawberry



excellent
excellent excellent









Chesapeake

















Chimney


excellent excellent












Clapper Flat

















Clarke's Pearmain

















Clark’s Orange

















Coble’s Wilder

















Coe

















Coffelt Beauty

















Coffey Seedling

















Collins

















Collins June






good









Conrad

















Cothren

















Cotton

















Crack

















Critt

good









good



Crow’s Egg



outstanding












Cullasaga

















Davidson Sweeting













prized


Deaderick

















Delicious

















Devine

















Disharoon

















Doctor

















Doctor Matthews

















Domine

















Donce

















Duchess of Oldenburg


superior


superior









Dula Beauty



good












Dumpling

















Durham

















Early Harvest



very good

very good









Early Joe



excellent












Early Red Bird



unfit
best

excellent




good

Early Red Margaret

















Early Ripe

















Early Strawberry





best










Edward’s Winter



used for












Emerging Blaze

















Enos

















Esopus Spitzenburg

















Fairgrove

















Fall Orange










prized





Fall Pippin

















Fall Premium

















Fallawater


used for













Fameuse in the North


in the North

in the North









Fanny



good












Farthing’s No Bloom

















Fired Sweet

















Flat Fall Cheese

















Flat Fallawater

















Fleming

















Floyd Richmond

















Foot Around





best good









Foust

















Fugate

















Fyan

















Gable

















Gano

















George Mack

















Gilmore’s Sweetening

















Gilpin good





good









Glass















delicious wine
Globe

















Gloria Mundi




prized
good









Golden Harvey



best






possibly excellent judging by its alias




Golden Pippin

















Golden Reinette



excellent












Golden Sweet blending



blending











Gragg

















Grandaddy

















Grandmother Cheese

















Granny Christian



good









great

Granny Mack

















Granny Neighbors



good












Gravenstein good

good good

very good


excellent





Green Cheese



good












Green Pippin

















Green River

















Grimes Golden excellent 18



outstanding










Grindstone good


poor












Grissom

















Guyandotte

















Haas

















Hackworth



used for
used for



used for





Hall



best












Hammond

















Harris

















Harrison excellent


used for












Hayes Green

















Haywood June

pink if cooked with peels


pink if cooked with peels










Hege

















Henry Clay

















Hewe’s Crab Mixed with the extinct Golden Wilding to make superior cider by Thomas Jefferson. George Washington described as “brisk subacid” best
















Hickman

















Hightop Sweet

















Hillside

















Hog Island Sweet



very good












Hog Sweet

















Holland Pippin






excellent









Hollow Log



best

best









Holly

















Honey Sweet good


good












Hoover



very good used for











Horse good
excellent good


good




good



Hubbardston Nonsuch

















Huffman Red


good













Hunge


good excellent

good



good




Huntsman’s Favorite



very good












Ingram excellent


excellent












Isam

















Jake’s Seedling



very good












Jarrett

















Jefferis

















Jersey Black

















Jim Day

















Jimbo




used for











Joe Little

















John






hold shape









John Conner

















Johnny No Core

















Johnson Keeper

















Jonalicious

















Jonathan

















Juicy Fruit



excellent












July Delicious

















July-August Go-No-Further

















Junaluska

















June Sweeting

















Kane

















Keener Seedling

good good very good
best good

good best





Kennedy

















Kimrome

















King David good


good

good









King Luscious

















King Solomon

















King Tom

















Kinnaird’s Choice



good












Lacy


good good

good

good






Lady

















Lady Skin

















Lady Sweet

















Ladyfinger

















Langdon


used for used for

used for









Lawson’s Seedling

















Lawver



fair

good









Leather Coat

















Lewis Green

















Appalachian Limbertwig excellent


excellent Excellent & very aromatic
excellent









Sweet Limbertwig



best












Brushy Mountain Limbertwig
















good, all purpose apple
Cane Creen Limbertwig

















Ben Lomand Limbertwig good
good good good good good good good good good good good good good good general purpose good general-purpose
Myer’s Royal Limbertwig best


excellent












Old Fashioned Limbertwig good


good





good





Swiss Limbertwig

















American Limbertwig

















Black Limbertwig prized



prized











Red Limbertwig

















Royal Limbertwig




Aromatic & delicious











Levering Limbertwig



fair












Rose Limbertwig

















Summer Limbertwig

















Red Royal Limbertwig



excellent












Rocky River Limbertwig



good












Little Benny



good

excellent








cooks with no lumps
Liveland Raspberry

















Longfield

















Long Stem



best












Lonnie’s Summer Giant



fair












Lowell



used for

used for









Lowry



very good












Lugar Red

















Magnum Bonum

















Maiden’s Blush


good fair
good very good








cooks lump-free; slices dry white
Mann



fair

very good









Mary McKinney



good

good









Mary Reid


good good

excellent









Mattamuskeet




outstanding











May






used for









McIntosh

















McLean

















Means Seedling

















Melungeon Gold

















Milam good










good




Miles Stadler

















Mississippi Pippin

















Missouri Pippin



good












Mitchell

















Mitchell Sweet

















Mongolian

















Morgan’s Christmas

















Mosey















best sulfuring apple
Mother excellent


excellent












Mother Bud





excellent



excellent





Mountain Beauty

















Mountain Boomer

















Mountain Rose

















Mrs. Bryan

















Munson Sweet

















Muskmelon Sweet

















Newtown Pippin very good


depends












Nickajack



average












North Carolina Keeper

















Northern Spy


poor excellent

excellent









Northwestern Greening






excellent


excellent





Old English Milam

















Oliver

















Ooten



good

very good









Opalescent

















Ophir





best good


very good





Ortley

















Ozark Beauty

















Parks’ Pippin used for
used for

used for











Parmer





used for




very good




Paw

















Pennock



poor












Perkins

















Perry Russet

















Pewaukee



poor












Phifer

















Pilot



best

best









Pineapple

















Pinky



used for

used for









Polly Eades

















Polly Sweet

















Pomme Grise

















Porter



good

good

good





holds its flavor & shape when cooked
Potomac

















Potts











very good




Pound

















Pound Pippin

















Primate

















Prissy Gum






used for









Pryor’s Red

















Pumpkin Sweet







very good
very good


very good very good very good stewed with quinces
Queen



very good












Rabun Bald



very good












Rainbow



very good












Ralls Janet

















Rambo

















Rattle Core

















Rawley

















Reaser Green

















Rebel

















Red Astrachan

good
fair
good very good


excellent




develops a strong quince flavor when cooked, makes a pink sauce
Red Bietigheimer

















Red Canada



very good












Red Cathead

















Red Cheese

















Red Delight



good












Red Detroit


excellent













Red Hackworth

















Red Rebel

















Red Reese

















Red Winter Sweet used for
















Regent



good












Republican Pippin


good


good









Reverend Morgan



good












Rexrode Beauty

















Rhode Island Greening



conditionally excellent











unfit if Southern-grown
Roanoke

















Robertson Red

















Romanite

















Roman Stem

















Rome Beauty



poor

excellent








I think they are crappy for cooking or eating. They’re just pretty.
Roxbury Russet used for


good












Andrews Rusty Coat

















Sally Gray


used for













Salome

















Sam Apple

















Sam Hunt

















Sam Whitson




very good very good










San Jacinto

















Schell

















Schumacher

















Scott’s Winter

















Shell



excellent












Shenandoah





excellent


excellent






Sherrill

















Shockley

















Short Core



good











good general-purpose
Sine Qua Non

















Slabside



excellent












Slope

















Smith Seedling






very good





used for very good
holds shape
Smith’s Cider good


good

good









Smith’s Seedling of Mississippi

















Smokehouse



good

excellent excellent








Snuff

















Sops of Wine

















Sour June





good used for
used for







Sparger




used for used for







used for

Spotted Pippin

















St. Clair



excellent












Stafford

















Stark

















Starr






used for









Stayman



very good












Striped Early Harvest

















Striped June

















Stump

















Stump The World

















Sugar



very good

poor









Sugar Loaf Pippin

















Sulser Red



excellent












Summer Banana

















Summer Champion

















Summer Cheese

















Summer King

















Summer Ladyfinger

















Summer Pippin

















Summer Pound Royal

















Summer Queen

















Summer Rambo





excellent



used for


used for

Summer Rose

















Sunday Sweet



best









best
holds its shape when cooked & has a “very spicy, aromatic taste” when fried
Surprise

















Sutton Beauty

















Swaar






poor









Sweet Bough



good

variable reviews









Sweet Dixon

















Sweet Lannie

















Sweet Russet

















Sweet Winesap



excellent












Taliafero best


unfit












Tanner’s Winter

















Tanyard Seedling

















Tarbutton

used for used for used for

used for









Taylor Sweet

















Ten Ounce

















Tenderskin

















Terry Winter

















Tetofsky






used for









Tewksbury Winter Blush

















Thompson of Mississippi

















Tolman Sweet good


unfit
poor









a steaming apple, suggesting it might be a good baker as well; holds its shape
Tom Jones Seedling



good
good










Tommy

















Tompkins King

















Tony


best
best best



best





Tucker

















Turley Winesap



not as good as Stayman

excellent









Twenty Ounce



fair

excellent









Van Hoy

















Vandevere very good
















Vandever June

















Vine

















Virginia Beauty



unfit












Virginia Greening

















Walker's Yellow

















Walter Tibbs

















Watermelon

















Wealthy

















Western Beauty

















White Winter Pearmain



excellent












Williams Favorite

















White Milan

















Willow Twig



poor












Wilson


used for
very good
very good


good





Wilson June

















Wine

















Winesap good


very good












Winter Banana



unfit

unfit









Winter Cheese










general purpose
Winter Jon good
good














Winter May

















Winter Sweet Paradise

















Wolf River


good unfit very good used for good








cooks smooth
World’s Best

















Wrixparent

















Yankee Sweet









good


excellent


Yates

















Yellow Bellflower excellent




excellent



excellent





Yellow Hardin











very good



makes a qt. more brandy/ bushel
Yellow June

















Yellow Potts

















Yellow Transparent

















York Imperial



excellent
very good


good





holds shape when canned
Table 3.

Tree Characteristics

Cultivar Scab Fireblight BitterRot CAR Collar rot Jonathan spot Powdery Mildew OtherDiseases CodlingMoth bloomTime YieldCycle Pollen Precocity SoilPreference GrowthHabit TreeComments
Abram









annual




Accordian















Alexander
susceptible













Alexander’s Ice Cream















Allum















American Beauty















American Golden Russet


susceptible





biennial

sandstone

American Summer Pearmain
susceptible










many

Amy















Andy Reed






“disease-resistant”







Arkansas Black susceptible





Disease-resistant except scab somewhat resistant






Arkansas Sweet















Arthur















Asterus















Atha















Aunt Cora’s















Aunt Rachel















Aunt Sally















Autumn Strawberry















Bald Mountain















Baldwin susceptible


resistant





biennial sterile (triploid)



Ball’s Choice















Balsam















Baltimore Monstrous Pippin















Bart















Beach









annual




Beauty of the World









annual




Beckham’s Seedling















Beecher















Belcher Mountain















Belmont












high, warm or limestone

Ben Davis moderately susceptible
moderately susceptible

susceptible





late annual




Benham moderate resistance
moderate resistance

moderate resistance






annual





Benoni moderately susceptible
moderately susceptible

susceptible






biennial
precocious
small
Bentley's Sweet moderately resistant
moderately resistant
very susceptible
moderately resistant











Betsy Deaton















Bevan’s Favorite moderately susceptible
moderately susceptible

moderately susceptible












Big Red















Big Stem















Billy Brown















Bishop















Bismarck











very precocious
very small
Black Amish









annual




Black Apple















Black Gilliflower moderately resistant
very susceptible
moderately resistant












Black Jack















Blacktwig
resistant
resistant




late


poor soils

Blairmont















Bloomless















Blue Ridge King















Boger















Bower's Nonpareil















Branch















Brichel Sweet













dwarf
Brogan








early/mid





Brogden















Brooks















Bryson’s Seedling















Buckeye Beauty















Buckingham


susceptible











Bud Wolf















Buff


very susceptible








finicky
quality suffers on soils it doesn’t like
Buncombe















Burl















Burning Green















Calvin















Camack’s Sweet















Cannon Pearmain resistant
resistant

resistant






biennial


mountain vigorous
tough wood, limbs seldom break
Captain Davis















Carolina Baldwin















Carolina Pippin















Carolina Red June susceptible

susceptible











Carter’s Blue moderate resistance
moderate resistance

susceptible





annual


widely adapted vigorous

Catawba















Cathead















Cauley resistant resistant when mature resistant





late



vigorous
very productive on its own roots; limbs seldom break
Chandler















Chatham Sweet















Chenango Strawberry
susceptible




susceptible to root rot, though it is surprising that the scion could affect this root trait so much







Chesapeake















Chimney















Clapper Flat















Clarke's Pearmain















Clark’s Orange















Coble’s Wilder















Coe















Coffelt Beauty















Coffey Seedling















Collins














needs judicious thinning to size
Collins June














unproductive
Conrad















Cothren















Cotton















Crack















Critt















Crow’s Egg















Cullasaga susceptible susceptible













Davidson Sweeting















Deaderick
resistant













Delicious














productive
Devine















Disharoon















Doctor















Doctor Matthews















Domine









biennial


straggling
Donce















Duchess of Oldenburg
susceptible









2-3 years


Dula Beauty












widely adapted

Dumpling















Durham















Early Harvest very susceptible








biennial

good soil tends to form twigs in groups of 2 or 3
Early Joe susceptible








biennial




Early Red Bird








very early





Early Red Margaret















Early Ripe resistant














Early Strawberry















Edward’s Winter













bears in clusters of 5-7
Emerging Blaze















Enos















Esopus Spitzenburg susceptible susceptible

susceptible susceptible









Fairgrove















Fall Orange















Fall Pippin susceptible








biennial

rich

Fall Premium















Fallawater


susceptible





biennial
precocious
vigorous
Fameuse susceptible








biennial




Fanny









annual


vigorous productive
Farthing’s No Bloom















Fired Sweet















Flat Fall Cheese















Flat Fallawater















Fleming















Floyd Richmond















Foot Around















Foust















Fugate















Fyan















Gable













Gano















George Mack















Gilmore’s Sweetening















Gilpin








late somewhat biennial


vigorous, sparse with curled leaves and sparse foliage
Glass















Globe















Gloria Mundi












rich

Golden Harvey















Golden Pippin















Golden Reinette

susceptible









dry, stony Semi-dwarf
Golden Sweet
susceptible







annual




Gragg















Grandaddy















Grandmother Cheese















Granny Christian













Granny Mack















Granny Neighbors















Gravenstein
susceptible
susceptible


susceptible to root rot, though it is surprising that the scion could affect this root trait so much


sterile (triploid)



Green Cheese susceptible







late biennial




Green Pippin















Green River















Grimes Golden resistant

resistant very susceptible



late




needs judicious thinning to size
Grindstone















Grissom















Guyandotte















Haas















Hackworth















Hall













Semi-dwarf very productive
Hammond















Harris















Harrison resistant





free of fruit rots







Hayes Green















Haywood June















Hege















Henry Clay















Hewe’s Crab















Hickman















Hightop Sweet















Hillside















Hog Island Sweet















Hog Sweet















Holland Pippin















Hollow Log








late annual



productive according to Calhoun and unproductive according to Kuffel Creek
Holly















Honey Sweet















Hoover
opposite evaluations; Calhoun cites someone who says its resistant













Horse








late

precocious


Hubbardston Nonsuch












highly variable with soils

Huffman Red















Hunge















Huntsman’s Favorite susceptible
susceptible











productive
Ingram








very late annual with proper thinning



productive; needs judicious thinning
Isam















Jake’s Seedling















Jarrett















Jefferis somewhat resistant













not very productive
Jersey Black















Jim Day















Jimbo















Joe Little















John







resistant






John Conner















Johnny No Core















Johnson Keeper















Jonalicious















Jonathan
very susceptible very susceptible very susceptible
susceptible very susceptible


biennial

rich

Juicy Fruit















July Delicious
resistant











perfect shape, naturally
July-August Go-No-Further















Junaluska















June Sweeting















Kane















Keener Seedling















Kennedy















Kimrome















King David resistant resistant
resistant




late





King Luscious tolerant very susceptible






1 week later than Rome Beauty very late annual


Semi-dwarf productive
King Solomon









biennial
slow to come in to bearing
vigorous productive
King Tom









annual


weird, weeping habit Tip-bearer
Kinnaird’s Choice








late





Lacy














roots easily
Lady susceptible





particularly susceptible to sooty blotch/ flyspeck complex

biennial
slow to come in to bearing
Semi-dwarf
Lady Skin















Lady Sweet somewhat susceptible








biennial




Ladyfinger















Langdon















Lawson’s Seedling















Lawver susceptible











clay
doesn’t do well at lower elevations
Leather Coat















Lewis Green















Appalachian Limbertwig






generally disease & pest resistant





Non-weeping productive
Sweet Limbertwig















Brushy Mountain Limbertwig resistant
resistant

resistant










Cane Creen Limbertwig















Ben Lomand Limbertwig















Myer’s Royal Limbertwig













Semi-weeping
Old Fashioned Limbertwig















Swiss Limbertwig















American Limbertwig















Black Limbertwig resistant
resistant

resistant resistant “generally resistant to fungal diseases”







Red Limbertwig















Royal Limbertwig















Levering Limbertwig














tetraploid
Rose Limbertwig














productive
Summer Limbertwig















Red Royal Limbertwig















Rocky River Limbertwig














not very productive
Little Benny







resistant




Semi-dwarf productive
Liveland Raspberry
resistant













Longfield















Long Stem















Lonnie’s Summer Giant















Lowell















Lowry











precocious


Lugar Red















Magnum Bonum


susceptible








high calcium
calcium sprays during fruit expansion important for quality
Maiden’s Blush susceptible susceptible
resistant





biennial




Mann















Mary McKinney















Mary Reid















Mattamuskeet


susceptible








rich loam vigorous productive
May















McIntosh















McLean















Means Seedling






generally disease & pest resistant







Melungeon Gold















Milam









annual



must be thinned for good size; tolerant of late Spring frosts
Miles Stadler















Mississippi Pippin















Missouri Pippin
very susceptible









2-3 years


Mitchell















Mitchell Sweet















Mongolian















Morgan’s Christmas















Mosey















Mother








late biennial


Semi-dwarf productive; needs judicious thinning
Mother Bud















Mountain Beauty















Mountain Boomer
susceptible













Mountain Rose















Mrs. Bryan















Munson Sweet















Muskmelon Sweet















Newtown Pippin
susceptible susceptible









no apple is more finicky about soils; needs good loamy soil

Nickajack
susceptible







annual

upper Piedmont & mountain soils suit it better

North Carolina Keeper















Northern Spy very susceptible very susceptible












bruises easily
Northwestern Greening















Old English Milam















Oliver















Ooten















Opalescent















Ophir















Ortley susceptible
susceptible











brittle wood
Ozark Beauty















Parks’ Pippin















Parmer












black loam or red clay
productive; only succeeds above 1k ft or up North
Paw















Pennock






particularly susceptible to sooty blotch/ flyspeck complex







Perkins















Perry Russet















Pewaukee















Phifer















Pilot









conditionally biennial

not clay
conditionally unproductive; as for YieldCycle, the condition is lower elevation/ warmer environments
Pineapple















Pinky















Polly Eades















Polly Sweet















Pomme Grise









annual



productive
Porter









biennial




Potomac















Potts















Pound















Pound Pippin















Primate















Prissy Gum















Pryor’s Red


very susceptible


very susceptible to “other fungal diseases” besides CAR




warm loam

Pumpkin Sweet
susceptible







biennial


Tip-bearer
Queen















Rabun Bald









biennial


stocky, vigorous, spreading
Rainbow















Ralls Janet
susceptible






late



twiggy, requires careful pruning needs judicious thinning to size
Rambo















Rattle Core















Rawley















Reaser Green















Rebel












Cecil clay

Red Astrachan susceptible







late





Red Bietigheimer












fertile, open soils

Red Canada















Red Cathead









annual



productive
Red Cheese















Red Delight
susceptible












ornamental pink blossoms
Red Detroit








late





Red Hackworth












Alabama

Red Rebel






Disease-resistant






very productive
Red Reese






“disease-resistant”







Red Winter Sweet















Regent













vigorous productive
Republican Pippin













crooked
Reverend Morgan






“resistant to several apple diseases”







Rexrode Beauty















Rhode Island Greening very susceptible








annual

friable, well-drained
requires judicious thinning
Roanoke








late




productive
Robertson Red















Romanite















Roman Stem














very productive
Rome Beauty somewhat susceptible somewhat susceptible






late annual
precocious


Roxbury Russet resistant

resistant





annual



productive
Andrews Rusty Coat















Sally Gray















Salome resistant













holds fruit well, productive
Sam Apple















Sam Hunt















Sam Whitson















San Jacinto















Schell















Schumacher















Scott’s Winter















Shell








very early




Low-chill
Shenandoah















Sherrill















Shockley









annual


upright productive
Short Core











precocious
Semi-dwarf, wood brittle & splits easily productive
Sine Qua Non















Slabside















Slope















Smith Seedling















Smith’s Cider








late annual

widely adapted
very productive, brittle wood
Smith’s Seedling of Mississippi















Smokehouse
susceptible
susceptible








widely adapted

Snuff















Sops of Wine









annual



productive
Sour June















Sparger















Spotted Pippin















St. Clair















Stafford















Stark
susceptible







annual



productive; often rots on the tree in warmer areas
Starr















Stayman










sterile (triploid)



Striped Early Harvest















Striped June















Stump















Stump The World















Sugar















Sugar Loaf Pippin















Sulser Red















Summer Banana















Summer Champion
susceptible













Summer Cheese















Summer King
susceptible







biennial


Semi-dwarf
Summer Ladyfinger















Summer Pippin















Summer Pound Royal











precocious


Summer Queen















Summer Rambo
susceptible







annual


vigorous
Summer Rose








late



slow grower productive
Sunday Sweet













Semi-dwarf productive
Surprise















Sutton Beauty
susceptible






very early biennial



earliest bloomer in Lee’s orchard
Swaar
susceptible susceptible






biennial

deep, rich sandy loam
prone to dropped fruit
Sweet Bough
susceptible













Sweet Dixon















Sweet Lannie















Sweet Russet















Sweet Winesap
susceptible









slow to come in to bearing


Taliafero















Tanner’s Winter















Tanyard Seedling








late





Tarbutton















Taylor Sweet















Ten Ounce















Tenderskin















Terry Winter















Tetofsky











very precocious


Tewksbury Winter Blush















Thompson of Mississippi















Tolman Sweet
susceptible













Tom Jones Seedling















Tommy














very productive
Tompkins King
susceptible

susceptible




biennial



less cold-hardy than most Northern apples
Tony















Tucker














very productive
Turley Winesap















Twenty Ounce
susceptible susceptible











susceptible to sunscald & canker; requires heavy pruning to keep top open
Van Hoy















Vandevere

conditionally susceptible









deep vegetable loams high in calcium
brittle wood; dropping
Vandever June















Vine













thin, wiry new growth
Virginia Beauty
resistant










widely adapted Wide-angles
Virginia Greening

susceptible












Walker's Yellow















Walter Tibbs















Watermelon















Wealthy











precocious

productive
Western Beauty














never water cores & not disposed to rot
White Winter Pearmain









annual

rich

Williams Favorite















White Milan

very susceptible












Willow Twig susceptible susceptible




susceptible to “other diseases” as well as those specified







Wilson















Wilson June















Wine












sandy loam small, curled leaves
Winesap
moderately resistant
immune




rather late annual sterile (triploid)
widely adapted straggling, drooping requires judicious thinning
Winter Banana
susceptible
susceptible




late biennial
2-3 years

bruises easily
Winter Cheese resistant
resistant

resistant





late annual




Winter Jon









annual




Winter May















Winter Sweet Paradise















Wolf River resistant susceptible



resistant




slow to come in to bearing
vigorous
World’s Best















Wrixparent
resistant




resistant to “other diseases”







Yankee Sweet















Yates
somewhat susceptible










light, well-drained
requires judicious thinning
Yellow Bellflower susceptible susceptible









slow to come in to bearing light, well-drained

Yellow Hardin















Yellow June















Yellow Potts















Yellow Transparent resistant very susceptible
resistant





biennial
precocious

requires judicious thinning to size, productive; the Perrine sport is supposed to be more resistant to blight, larger & on a smaller tree
York Imperial
very susceptible
very susceptible


also susceptible to cork spot; rotting & dropping rampant at lower elevations

biennial





References other than Old Southern Apples, by Lee Calhoun, Jr. & Notes (Color-coded)
Orange: An Auburn apples bulletin.
Fushia:  Big Horse Creek Farm
Yellow:  unknown or lost source
Purple:  Kuffel Creek Apple Tree Nursery
Deep Blue:  Century Farm Orchards.
Light Blue:  My own experience.
Red:  It's rare for my own experience to differ with that of Lee's descriptions and in most cases, I have no experience with the apple in question. Despite my family having lived in the rural South since before 1655, I have first-hand experience with a few dozen kinds of Southern apples, whereas Lee has experienced hundreds. Nevertheless, in those rare instances when my experience differs dramatically from Lee's I've highlighted it in red, though I stayed with Lee's characterization.